Unfortunately, yes. There’s no contest. No competition. And for us professionals in the pool industry, we can only accept this bitter truth.
It’s quite possible that even you, who are thinking about building your own swimming pool, have started reflecting on it and are already tempted by the idea of a hot tub.
If we compare the advantages of a hot tub with those of a swimming pool, the hot tub may seem like the more sensible and rational choice.
Why the Hot Tub Seems to Win
Let’s take a closer look at the matter.
BUREAUCRATIC ASPECTS: no permits are required to install a hot tub in your garden or terrace, unlike a swimming pool, which involves several administrative steps.
DESIGN ASPECTS: a swimming pool requires careful planning of the surrounding space, while a hot tub does not.
COSTS: although there are very expensive hot tubs (€15,000–€20,000), these costs never come close to those of a swimming pool.
USAGE PERIOD: a swimming pool is mainly used during summer or, thanks to a heat pump, also throughout May, June, September, and October. A hot tub, on the other hand, is designed to be enjoyed all year round, even when it snows.
MAINTENANCE: a hot tub requires very little maintenance. It can be drained and refilled with fresh water in just a few hours. Everything is much simpler when compared to a swimming pool.
INSTALLATION TIME: half a day for a hot tub, months for a swimming pool.
ENJOYMENT AND HYDROTHERAPY BENEFITS: a hot tub is a genuine wellness tool. Its different seating positions provide targeted massages for various parts of the body. Hydrotherapy can also be integrated into a swimming pool, but it is not the same. The pool basin is much larger and, as a result, the jet pressure loses intensity. In addition, a hot tub can feature up to 50–60 jets, while swimming pools generally have far fewer.
It seems obvious, then, that the hot tub wins this challenge, right?
On the surface, absolutely. But in reality?
Why the Swimming Pool Remains Unbeatable
Beyond all the advantages that a swimming pool offers compared to a hot tub:
- Swimming
- Playing in the water
- Outdoor lunches and dinners
- Hosting poolside parties
- Inviting friends and family
Not to mention the visual impact and the ability to enjoy a more complete relaxation experience, all of which make a swimming pool clearly superior in terms of perceived value.
If you buy an outdoor hot tub, you can’t really invite people over and say, “Come to my house, I’ve got a hot tub!”.
With a swimming pool, however, let’s be honest, you absolutely can.
A swimming pool becomes a place where you welcome friends and family, spend quality time together, and create unforgettable memories.
This is exactly where the swimming pool plays a completely different game.
This is the real reason why there is no competition between a swimming pool and a hot tub.
Swimming Pool and Hot Tub: The Ideal Solution Exists
In reality, the best solution is not choosing between a swimming pool and a hot tub, but having both.
There are many design solutions that allow a hydrotherapy area to be integrated directly into the swimming pool, or a hot tub to be positioned alongside the pool, creating a complete and perfectly balanced wellness environment.
This way, you get the best of everything: relaxation, hydrotherapy, entertainment, and aesthetic value for your outdoor space.
We have been designing and building swimming pools in the Marche, Umbria, and Abruzzo regions for almost 40 years. If you are considering a project for your outdoor living space, contact us for a personalized consultation.
We will help you transform your garden into a tailor-made wellness retreat designed around your lifestyle.